From Publishers Weekly
Starred Review. Fortified with Eeyoreish fatalism—I'm already unhappy.
I have nothing to lose—Weiner set out on a yearlong quest to find the
world's unheralded happy places. Having worked for years as an NPR
foreign correspondent, he'd gone to many obscure spots, but usually to
report bad news or terrible tragedies. Now he'd travel to countries
like Iceland, Bhutan, Qatar, Holland, Switzerland, Thailand and India
to try to figure out why residents tell positive psychology researchers
that they're actually quite happy. At his first stop, Rotterdam's World
Database of Happiness, Weiner is confronted with a few inconvenient
truths. Contrary to expectations, neither greater social equality nor
greater cultural diversity is associated with greater happiness.
Iceland and Denmark are very homogeneous, but very happy; Qatar is
extremely wealthy, but Weiner, at least, found it rather depressing. He
wasn't too fond of the Swiss, either, uncomfortable with their quiet
satisfaction, tinged with just a trace of smugness. In the end, he
realized happiness isn't about economics or geography. Maybe it's not
even personal so much as relational. In the end, Weiner's travel
tales—eating rotten shark meat in Iceland, smoking hashish in
Rotterdam, trying to meditate at an Indian ashram—provide great
happiness for his readers.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From The Washington Post
Reviewed by Daniel Gilbert
In
the last two decades, psychologists and economists have learned a lot
about happiness, including who's happy and who isn't. The Dutch are,
the Romanians aren't, and Americans are somewhere in between. Eric
Weiner -- a peripatetic journalist and self-proclaimed grump -- wanted
to know why. So with science as his compass, he spent a year visiting
the world's most and least happy places, and the result is a charming,
funny and illuminating travelogue called The Geography of Bliss.
From
the Persian Gulf to the Arctic Circle, Weiner discovers that happiness
blooms where we least expect it. Who knew that the long, dark Icelandic
winter gives rise to a magical, communal culture that has done away
with envy and sobriety? Or that the Thais so prize "fun" that their
government has created a Gross Domestic Happiness Index to ensure they
get enough of it? Or that Moldovans are miserable because they "derive
more pleasure from their neighbor's failure than their own success"? Or
that the wealthy citizens of Qatar lead pampered, joyless lives in a
"gilded sandbox" while the poor citizens of Bhutan are cheerfully
obsessed with archery tournaments, penis statues and feeding marijuana
to their fat (and presumably happy) pigs?
But Weiner does more
than report on the lifestyles of the delighted and despondent. He
participates -- meditating in Bangalore, visiting strip clubs in
Bangkok and drinking himself into a stupor in Reykjavik. These cultural
forays are entertaining, but the real focus of his story is on the
people he meets in cafés and on buses, the people who rent him rooms
and give him directions, the people whose conversations, confessions
and silences reveal the deep truths about their lands and lives.
Weiner
asks an Icelander whether he believes in elves, and the man replies, "I
don't know if I believe in them, but other people do and my life is
richer for it," leading Weiner to conclude that Icelanders "occupy the
space that exists between not believing and not not believing. It is
valuable real estate." He meets a widower in Slough -- a small town
outside London with little to recommend it -- who explains that he's
thought about moving away but that in the end "you come home because
this is where you live." Weiner realizes that when our relationships
end, "the place is all that remains, and to leave would feel like a
betrayal. . . . He doesn't love Slough, but he loved his wife, loved
her here, in this much-maligned Berkshire town, so here he stays."
Memory, like bliss, seems to have its own address.
Weiner has
studied the scientific literature on happiness, too, and weaves it into
his narrative, which he leavens with a steady stream of clever quips.
We learn that "Bhutan has made tremendous strides in the kind of
metrics that people who use words like metrics get excited about" and
that "hairpin turns, precipitous drop-offs (no guardrails), and a
driver who firmly believes in reincarnation make for a nerve-racking
experience."
Weiner, a correspondent for National Public Radio,
is an American who unapologetically indulges his ethnic stereotypes
("Watching Brits shed their inhibitions is like watching elephants
mate. You know it happens, it must, but it's noisy, awkward as hell and
you can't help but wonder: Is this something I really need to see?"),
but if you want to wag a politically correct finger in his direction,
you'll have to stop laughing first.
Weiner's book is so good that
its occasional flaws stand out in sharp relief. He is smart and funny
but doesn't always trust his readers to know that, which leads him to
step on his punch lines and belabor his conclusions. Sometimes, he
settles for clichés ("Happiness is a choice") and platitudes ("Some
things are beyond measuring") instead of reaching for richer and
subtler insights. And while he expertly brings us into the lives of
every stranger on a train, he plays his own cards close to the chest.
He tells us a lot about his obsession with satchels, for instance, but
only in passing does he mention that he's a father. After traveling so
long and so far together, we should know him better than that.
One
of the ineluctable laws of travel is that most companions are beguiling
at the beginning and annoying by the end. Weiner's company wears
surprisingly well. It takes a chapter or two to decide you like him,
and another to realize that you like him a lot, but by the time the
trip is over, you find yourself hoping that you'll hit the road
together again someday. The Geography of Bliss is a journey too good to
be rare.
Copyright 2008, The Washington Post. All Rights Reserved.
From Bookmarks Magazine
If there’s one truth that emerged from reviewers’ various takes on The Geography of Bliss,
it’s that happiness is subjective. Every critic seemed to find
something that really irked him or her about this book: Weiner’s
persona seems affected, he indulges in "psychobabble," he remains aloof
about himself, he comes across as an obnoxious reporter. Yet everyone
seemed to enjoy his book, admiring Weiner’s original approach to the
subject, his balance of research and experience, and the characters
that illustrate the lessons on happiness Weiner accumulates during his
journeys. In short, all the critics’ happiness was alike, but they were
also all unhappy in their own way. (Sorry, Tolstoy.) FYI: Weiner lives
in Miami, Florida.
Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc.
Review
"Part travelogue, part
personal-discovery memoir and all sustained delight, this wise, witty
ramble reads like Paul Theroux channeling David Sedaris on a
particularly good day..... Fresh and beguiling."
(Kirkus Reviews )
"Laugh. Think. Repeat. Repeatedly. If someone told me this book was this good, I wouldn't have believed them." (Po Bronson, author of What Should I Do With My Life? )
"With
one single book, Eric Weiner has flushed Bill Bryson down a proverbial
toilet, and I say that lovingly. By turns hilarious and profound, this
is the kind of book that could change your life. The relationship
between place and contentment is an ineffable one, and Weiner cuts
through the fog with a big, powerful light. The Geography of Bliss is no smiley-face emoticon, it's a Winslow Homer."
(Henry Alford, author of Municipal Bondage and Big Kiss )
"Think Don Quixote
with a dark sense of humor and a taste for hashish and you begin to
grasp Eric Weiner, the modern knight-errant of this mad, sad, wise, and
witty quest across four continents. I won't spoil the fun by telling if
his mission succeeds, except to say that happiness is reading a book as
entertaining as this." (Tony Horwitz, author of Confederates in the Attic )
Product Description
Part foreign affairs
discourse, part humor, and part twisted self-help guide, The Geography
of Bliss takes the reader from America to Iceland to India in search of
happiness, or, in the crabby author's case, moments of
"un-unhappiness." The book uses a beguiling mixture of travel,
psychology, science and humor to investigate not what happiness is, but
where it is. Are people in Switzerland happier because it is the most
democratic country in the world? Do citizens of Qatar, awash in
petrodollars, find joy in all that cash? Is the King of Bhutan a
visionary for his initiative to calculate Gross National Happiness? Why
is Asheville, North Carolina so damn happy? With engaging wit and
surprising insights, Eric Weiner answers those questions and many
others, offering travelers of all moods some interesting new ideas for
sunnier destinations and dispositions. (2007)
About the Author
Eric Weiner, an
award-winning foreign correspondent for NPR and a former reporter for
the New York Times, has written stories from more than three dozen
countries, including Iraq, Afghanistan, and Indonesia. His commentary
has appeared in The New Republic, The International Herald Tribune, and
The Los Angeles Times, and he writes the popular "How They Do It"
column for Slate. He has lived in New Delhi, Jerusalem and Tokyo.